House of the Dragon is TV’s least essential show

I wish House of the Dragon were bad, because then it might at least make me feel something. 

When a TV show is bad, you want to talk about it, debate it, understand how it all went so horribly wrong or even revel in the absurdities of its failures. 

But when season three of House of the Dragon finally ended, I felt none of those things. A show that delivered eight episodes of dragons, battles and bloodshed left me with just one question: what was the point?

Season 3, episode 1 (Salt and Sea, Fire and Blood), was a genuinely thrilling hour of television. 

The Battle of the Gullet took its place in the pantheon of great Game of Thrones battles, and the death of Jace, heir to the throne, was a moment that raised the stakes and shook our understanding of the world. 

The Black army’s victory helped deliver King’s Landing to Rhaenyra and a series whose first two seasons felt mired in an endless setup finally felt ready to take off and soar with the power of a dragon. 

How. Wrong. We. Were. 

After eight episodes of thrilling battles, dragon fights and palace intrigue, by the time the credits rolled on episode 8 (The Treasons at Tumbleton), the reality of HotD’s world had not fundamentally changed.

Rhaenyra sits on the throne. Daemon kills people. Alicent worries. Aemond stumbles around Harrenhal. 

Even Helaena’s death, the finale’s most obviously irreversible event, has no real impact. She spent much of the season offering prophecies no one understood or acted upon, then died too late for her absence to reshape a single decision. 

Great dramatic television is about transformation. 

The war between Lord Hightower and Queen Rhaenyra should have destroyed the reality we understood in episode one and forced the characters to make choices they would have once considered unthinkable.

It’s not to say that nothing changed in season three, but for all of its blood and fire, the ending felt like it delivered us back to the beginning with just a few more scars. 

In the original Game of Thrones, the execution of Ned Stark and the Red Wedding massacre were more than moments that shocked us; they completely reframed our understanding of the show.

By contrast, House of the Dragon’s biggest season three moments rarely changed the characters or the world. 

Ser Criston Cole dies in battle, and almost no one notices. 

Lord Hightower dies without ever having really threatened Rhaenyra’s power. 

Lord Corlys is kidnapped and then returned, minus a finger. 

So many incidents, but so little consequence.

So where did it all go wrong?

Ormund Hightower made a strong enough start to things by tricking Daemon with a fake heir, but what did he accomplish after that?

He successfully destroyed the Gold Cloaks, yet King’s Landing didn’t fall into chaos and ruin; it wasn’t overrun by bandits or outlaws. If anything, that arc showed that maybe the Gold Cloaks weren’t as important as we thought they were. 

In the battle against Rhaenyra’s army, his men were so badly outnumbered and unprepared that they crumbled the first time they faced real combat.

His master plan of recruiting Ulf White backfired when the dragon rider decided to destroy both armies. 

The final episode revealed that Lord Hightower’s grand strategy was never much more than a grand delusion.

When Rhaenyra revealed herself in full black armor, it seemed like she was finally ready to take matters into her own hands and step into her power.

It would have been a satisfying contrast. In episode one, she was locked in her room during the grand battle; now in episode eight she would lead her own fights. 

When she threatened the life of the High Septon, I immediately thought of Ned Stark telling his sons that the man who issues the verdict should carry out the sentence. 

Here was a moment for the dark inverse of that logic. A chance to watch Queen Rhaenyra go from sheltered monarch to a leader who makes violence personal.

If she had taken sword in hand and finished the Septon herself, that turn would have given us an entirely new character. Instead, she turns to Alyn of Hull and once again has someone else do her dirty work while she walks away to give a speech.

Killing the Septon was a dramatic moment, but because he was a minor character who never had much impact on the story, his death at the hands of another minor character felt shocking without feeling important.

Aegon Targaryen’s reunion with his brother Aemond was the episode’s best scene, containing humor, sweetness and danger and, just as importantly, it embodied all of the ways Aegon has changed since we first met him. 

Aegon fled the castle, fought for his survival, lived as a peasant, killed with his own hands, and ultimately resolved to die as king rather than flee from the Black Army, only to be saved at the last minute by Sunfyre. 

The war happened to Aegon, and he is a different man because of it. He may not be a good ruler, but he is now prepared to be a dangerous one. 

Giving Aegon a meaningful arc is an indictment of the writers failing to do the same for the rest of the characters. 

Battles matter when they destroy possibilities, and deaths matter when they leave behind a world that cannot be restored.

A television season earns its right to exist when it transforms our understanding of its characters and story. After eight episodes of blood, fire and chaos, House of the Dragon gave viewers spectacle without giving them meaningful change.

That’s why it left me with the question of how a series that feels so big could leave so little behind.

Original reporting, revealing interviews and thoughtful criticism—delivered to your inbox.